A redemption arc is one of the most powerful character journeys in storytelling. It revolves around a character who starts in a morally flawed state and gradually changes, seeking to atone for past mistakes and transform into a better version of themselves.
To make this arc compelling, we need more than just a series of events. We need to explore the emotional depth of the character through elements like the truth, the lie, the ghost, what the character wants, and what the character needs.
By integrating these elements with the classic three-act structure, we can craft a redemption arc that is both emotionally satisfying and narratively cohesive. Let’s break down how to do this step by step.
Act 1: The flawed beginning
The Truth
In Act 1, the character begins with a deep flaw or moral corruption. At this stage, the character is blind to their deeper truth or refuses to acknowledge it. This truth is the core of the character's inner conflict—the essential realization they must face in order to redeem themselves. It’s often linked to past actions or unresolved feelings that define the character's identity.
For example:
- The truth might be that the character has hurt others for selfish gain, but they convince themselves that they are justified in doing so.
- A villain may believe they were always acting for a noble cause, even though their methods were harmful.
The Lie
While the truth remains hidden, the character operates under a lie—a false belief that distorts their perception of themselves and the world. This lie can be an illusion of control, power, or righteousness, or a belief that they are incapable of change. The character's arc will involve confronting this lie head-on in order to grow.
In the beginning, the character might believe:
- That their actions are justified ("I did what I had to do").
- That they are beyond saving or incapable of redemption ("People don’t change").
The Ghost
A ghost is an emotional or psychological baggage from the past that haunts the character. It could be guilt, regret, trauma, or an unresolved relationship that continues to shape their behavior and choices. The ghost is often the source of the character's inner turmoil, and it drives their current actions. It's the thing that needs to be faced and dealt with in order for redemption to happen.
For example:
- A soldier who has committed war crimes might be haunted by the faces of those they’ve wronged.
- A former leader might feel responsible for the destruction they’ve caused and live with the ghost of their past decisions.
The Inciting Incident
The inciting incident is the catalyst that forces the character to confront their flaws and the consequences of their actions. It might involve an event that directly challenges their belief in the lie they’ve been telling themselves or brings the ghost of their past to the forefront.
The inciting incident serves as the character’s “wake-up call,” an event that forces them to reconsider their actions or beliefs. This moment shifts the narrative from the character’s normal life into the journey of redemption.
For example:
- The soldier witnesses the aftermath of their past actions, or a new conflict forces them to face the people they’ve hurt.
- The former leader experiences the loss of power or sees firsthand the effects of their rule on innocent lives.
At this point, the character doesn’t immediately change, but they begin to question themselves. The inciting incident opens a door to the possibility of redemption.
What the character wants
In the beginning, what the character wants is often tied to their flaws or desires for power, control, revenge, or self-preservation. They might want to hold onto their current life, justify their actions, or protect themselves from emotional vulnerability. The character’s external goal might be to overcome a physical obstacle, attain power, or simply survive.
For example:
- The soldier might want to escape from their past or find a way to suppress their guilt.
- The leader might want to reclaim their throne or justify their past actions to maintain control.
However, what the character wants is often not aligned with what they truly need for redemption.
Act 2: The struggle for change
Plot Point One
Plot Point One is the moment that launches the character into the second act. It’s a major event that forces the character into the journey of redemption. Here, they begin taking steps toward changing, but they haven’t fully embraced it yet.
It’s at this point that what the character needs becomes clear. While they may have desired something external (like power or safety), they need something deeper—self-awareness, forgiveness, healing, or reconciliation. The conflict between their wants and needs drives the emotional depth of their arc.
For example:
- The soldier might decide to seek out the victims of their past actions, realizing that they need to atone for the harm they’ve caused.
- The leader might start realizing that regaining power is no longer what matters; healing the world they’ve damaged is what they truly need.
Rising Action
The rising action is where the character struggles to reconcile their past mistakes with their desire for change. They might take small steps toward redemption but face obstacles and temptations that pull them back into their old ways. The ghost continues to haunt them, and the character’s inner conflict intensifies.
During this period, the character may attempt to do good, but their old habits die hard. They might fall short, fail, or make mistakes that make them question whether they can ever truly change. This struggle is crucial to keeping the audience engaged and rooting for the character’s eventual transformation.
Midpoint
At the midpoint, the character faces a major turning point that shifts their perspective. This is the moment when they fully confront the lie they’ve been living under. The realization may be painful, but it sets the stage for real growth.
This might be the moment the character faces the truth of their past actions or fully understands how much damage they’ve caused. It’s the emotional climax of the second act, where the character is forced to see themselves as they really are and must make a crucial decision about whether to continue their journey toward redemption.
For example:
- The soldier could meet the loved ones of those they’ve killed, forcing them to truly see the consequences of their actions.
- The leader might be confronted by someone they’ve hurt or betrayed, forcing them to face the depth of their wrongdoings.
Crisis
The crisis is the moment when the character faces the biggest emotional challenge of their redemption arc. They may be tempted to abandon their journey or revert to their old ways. Often, this moment tests their commitment to redemption and forces them to face the hardest truth: whether they can truly change or not.
This is the point where the character must confront their deepest fears, guilt, or shame. It’s a moment of self-doubt, where they question whether they deserve redemption.
For example:
- The soldier might face a situation that tests their resolve to change—perhaps they’re forced to make a choice that will have moral consequences.
- The leader could be given the opportunity to regain power through dishonorable means, forcing them to choose between the past and the possibility of a better future.
Act 3: The redemption and resolution
Plot Point Two
Plot Point Two is the moment that drives the character toward their final transformation. Here, the character commits to their redemption, despite the challenges they face. They may make a major sacrifice, or take an action that proves they are truly changed.
The character has learned that what they need is not external power, success, or revenge, but inner peace, forgiveness, or self-acceptance. The resolution of their internal conflict sets them on a path toward redemption.
Climax
The climax is the decisive moment where the character’s transformation is fully tested. This is the point where the character’s actions will prove whether they have truly changed. It’s the final test of redemption, where the character must act in a way that aligns with their new moral compass.
For example:
- The soldier might make a self-sacrificial act to protect others, showing they’ve learned the value of life and forgiveness.
- The leader might give up their power or use it for the greater good, demonstrating humility and growth.
Climactic Moment
In this final moment, the character’s redemption is complete. They have fully embraced the truth about themselves, let go of the lie they once believed, and found peace with their ghost. They have earned the right to be redeemed.
Resolution
In the resolution, the character has undergone a permanent transformation. While their past may never fully go away, they have made amends, forgiven themselves, or reconciled with others. The resolution shows that the character is now living in accordance with their new values, and they have successfully completed their redemption arc.
For example:
- The soldier may begin a new life dedicated to helping those they once harmed.
- The leader might rule with wisdom and compassion, having learned from their past mistakes.
THE VILLAIN WORKBOOK
