In fiction, perfect characters are rarely interesting. It's the flaws, vices, and questionable choices that make characters memorable and toxic traits can be powerful tools for writers to deepen conflict, raise the stakes, and reveal psychological nuance. Understanding toxic traits can help you write characters that feel authentic and emotionally provocative.
Here are 20 toxic traits to consider when building your next unforgettable character during your writing process.
1. Manipulativeness
This character sees people as tools to be used. Whether they gaslight, guilt-trip, or twist the truth, manipulative characters often maintain control through psychological tactics. Think of the charming antagonist who always gets their way, until they don’t.
Example: The overly helpful friend who always “needs” something in return.
2. Narcissism
Narcissistic characters are obsessed with their self-image and need constant validation. They often overestimate their abilities, minimize others’ contributions, and lash out at criticism.
Key conflict: Their fragile ego could unravel relationships or sabotage their own ambitions.
3. Vindictiveness
These characters never let things go. Every slight is a debt to be repaid. Whether through petty sabotage or long-term revenge plots, their inability to forgive makes them dangerous.
Great for: Building tension that spans an entire series.
4. Jealousy
A character ruled by jealousy is constantly comparing themselves to others, often irrationally. This can lead to betrayal, self-sabotage, or sabotage of others.
Jealous characters often turn on allies just when they’re needed most.
5. Controlling Behavior
This toxic trait stems from fear or entitlement. A controlling character might micromanage relationships, dictate others' choices, or cross boundaries under the guise of "helping."
Twist: They might genuinely believe they’re protecting others.
6. Two-Facedness
Duplicitous characters say one thing and do another. They wear different masks depending on who they’re with, keeping others in the dark about their true motives.
Excellent for: Political intrigue, psychological thrillers, or high-stakes drama.
7. Addictiveness
While addiction itself is not inherently a “toxic trait,” characters who let their addiction dictate behavior often exhibit toxic tendencies like lying, stealing, or abandoning responsibility.
Note: This can be written with nuance to avoid harmful stereotypes.
8. Gaslighting
A gaslighter distorts reality to maintain control. They may deny events, shift blame, or make others question their sanity, all to preserve power or image.
Impact: Victims of gaslighting often lose trust in themselves.
9. Passive-Aggressiveness
Instead of addressing issues directly, these characters use sarcasm, guilt-trips, or subtle jabs. This can erode trust and escalate conflicts in unexpected ways.
A great slow-burn trait for domestic fiction or relationship dramas.
10. Martyr Complex
This character constantly sacrifices themselves in ways that seem noble but they do it to manipulate others or feel superior. They make others feel guilty for their own choices.
Plot device: They may “suffer” loudly, forcing others to care for them.
11. Arrogance
Arrogant characters are often blind to their own flaws. Their overconfidence leads to poor decisions, fractured relationships, and sometimes spectacular downfalls.
Use for: Hubris arcs, especially in fantasy or tragic stories.
12. Lack of Empathy
Whether through trauma or sociopathy, a character who can’t (or won’t) feel others’ pain may behave cruelly, coldly, or mechanically.
Great for: Complex villains or calculating protagonists.
13. Martinet Mentality
A strict, rule-bound character may enforce discipline or morality to a toxic degree. They value rules over people, leading to rigid, even dangerous behavior.
Adds tension: When their “order” causes more harm than good.
14. Blame-Shifting
They never take responsibility. Every mistake is someone else’s fault: an enemy, a family member, or fate. This trait can mask insecurity or deep guilt.
Potential arc: Learning accountability could be their biggest struggle.
15. Greed
Greedy characters always want more: more power, money, status. Their hunger often blinds them to consequences, turning allies into enemies.
Effective in: Corporate thrillers, fantasy power struggles, or political dramas.
16. Emotional Immaturity
These characters act impulsively, take things personally, or can’t handle conflict. Their inability to grow emotionally creates recurring problems for themselves and others.
Common in: Coming-of-age stories or redemption arcs.
17. Chronic Lying
Lying becomes second nature to them, even when the truth would suffice. It may start as self-preservation but often spirals into identity confusion or betrayal.
Powerful when: The truth finally catches up to them.
18. Envy
Unlike jealousy, envy doesn’t just want what others have, it resents others for having it. Envious characters may undermine or sabotage those they admire.
Twist: They might idolize someone they eventually destroy.
19. Martial Toxicity
This trait shows up in characters who use dominance, intimidation, or violence to exert control in relationships. It can be written to explore cycles of abuse or power dynamics.
Warning: Handle with care and sensitivity.
20. Fatalism
A fatalistic character believes nothing they do will change their fate. This apathy often leads to inaction, self-destruction, or dragging others down with them.
Potential conflict: They may resist change, even when it’s clearly needed.
Conclusion
Toxic traits aren’t just for villains. Heroes, too, can harbor damaging behaviors that complicate their journey. The key to writing them well is intentionality: know how the trait influences their decisions, how others respond to it, and whether (or how) they change over time.
Use these flaws to add grit to your characters, complexity to your conflicts, and realism to your relationships. In the end, it’s the broken parts that make characters whole.
BUNDLE - CHARACTER WORKBOOKS
